Rising Inequality Hit us Twice: Once During Recession and Again in Recovery


Inequality doesn’t cause every problem in our world today. Inequality just makes every problem worse.

Big problems especially. Like recessions.

We’ve known for some time that recessions—and depressions—become much more likely when wealth starts excessively concentrating in the pockets of the already rich.

Now we have important new research that adds to this story. The same inequality that gets us into economic messes, it turns out, significantly slows the clean-up.

The research comes from an international team of economists who’ve just examined how Americans at different levels of wealth behaved economically before and during the Great Recession. What did American households spend, the investigators asked, and what did they save?

The researchers—the University of Pennsylvania’s Dirk Krueger, the University of Stockholm’s Kurt Mitman, and Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis analyst Fabrizio Perri—essentially found what they expected for the period right before the Great Recession. The lower a household’s net worth in 2006,  the higher that household’s consumption rate.

On this front, there was no surprise. Poorer households typically spend a higher share of their incomes than richer families. The goods and services their families need just to get by on a daily basis grab almost all of their incomes.

Richer households, on the other hand, spend far more total dollars on goods and services than poorer families. But they also make far more. With their pockets overflowing, they can afford to save a substantial share of their incomes.

This dynamic becomes more pronounced in any economy growing more unequal. The wealthier the rich become, the more they save. That’s all to the good, the pals of plutocrats insist. Savings by the rich, they assure us, create prosperity as the rich invest in businesses that create jobs. Everybody wins.

In real life, rising inequality limits most all winning to the wealthy. Those savings that rich people have to invest don’t go to businesses that create good jobs because average people—in an economy that’s concentrating rewards at the top—can’t afford to be good customers.

With job-creating businesses struggling, the rich take their savings elsewhere. They speculate. Enter our bubble economy.

The huge downside to all this: All bubbles eventually pop. The great housing bubble of the early 21st century would pop into 2008’s Great Recession.

So what happened with the consumption and savings patterns of America’s households? Here’s where the new research from economists Krueger, Mitman, and Perri gets particularly interesting. The trio found a striking “change in consumption expenditures at different points in the wealth distribution” after the Great Recession hit.

Between 2006 and 2010 saving rates increased most strongly “at the bottom of the wealth distribution.” How could less affluent households suddenly afford to save more? During the Great Recession, they cut their consumption at twice the rate of more affluent households.

And that behavior made eminent sense. These less affluent households—essentially the poorest 40 percent of Americans—held less than one percent of the nation’s wealth going into the Great Recession. In 2008, with people losing jobs left and right, these households cut back their spending markedly and started “to save massively” to protect themselves from the shock of job loss.

But what makes sense for particular households, the researchers make plain, didn’t make sense for the economy as a whole. With the nation’s less affluent spending less, businesses cut back more, and the nation’s economic mess just became messier. The recovery sputtered.

In an ideal world, unemployment insurance would prevent this sort of downward spiral. Unemployment benefits give families at the economic edge a modicum of security. Households that can count on these benefits to cushion the shock of job loss will continue to consume. Their consumption, in turn, helps a troubled economy recover.

Unemployment insurance in our contemporary United States, unfortunately, remains too spotty to offer any appreciable real security. In the Great Recession, less affluent households felt—rightly—on their own

If poorer Americans had unemployment benefit security during the depth of the Great Recession—and, more importantly, if poorer Americans had had a larger share of the nation’s wealth—the nation would have consumed more after the Great Recession hit. The recovery would have been more robust.

Without wealth inequality, as economist Dirk Krueger told one interviewer earlier this month, we still would have had a drop-off in overall consumption during the Great Recession. But that drop “would not have been as large”—and America’s worst economic downturn since the Great Depression would not have lasted as long and been as hard.

Still another good reason, as if we need one more, to make America more equal.

The post Rising Inequality Hit us Twice: Once During Recession and Again in Recovery appeared first on Institute for Policy Studies.

Sam Pizzigati is an associate fellow at the Institute for Policy Studies.


Benin cotton output has dropped by third during 2015-2016 season – Business Recorder (press release) (registration) (blog)

Business Recorder (press release) (registration) (blog)
Benin cotton output has dropped by third during 2015-2016 season
Business Recorder (press release) (registration) (blog)
COTONOU: Cotton production in Benin plunged by more than a third during the most recent season, President Patrice Talon said in an interview with the French newspaper Le Monde. Output by Africa's third-largest cotton producer was 260,000 tonnes during …

and more »


Officials encourage water safety during Labor Day holiday – Brownsville Herald

Brownsville Herald
Officials encourage water safety during Labor Day holiday
Brownsville Herald
Labor Day is the last big weekend of summer, so we can't afford to let down our guard this weekend,” said DFPS Commissioner John Specia. “Too many children have already lost their lives.” Texas is on pace so far in 2015 to surpass last year's total of

and more »


Assembly bill could give farmworkers a greater voice during mediation – Fresno Bee

Assembly bill could give farmworkers a greater voice during mediation
Fresno Bee
Patterson's Assembly Bill 1389, the Fair Contracts for California Farmworkers Act, is in response to the plight of Gerawan workers who have, so far, been unsuccessful in trying to oust the United Farm Workers union. Anti-union workers are angry because


OSHA urges retailers to keep workers safe during major sales events

As the holiday season approaches, the U.S. Department of Labor’s Occupational Safety and Health Administration is encouraging retail employers to implement safety measures to prevent workplace injuries during major sales events, including Black Friday.|||||||http://www.dol.gov/opa/media/press/osha/OSHA20142095.htm

MEDIA AVAILABILITY: Critics of EU-US Trade Negotiations Voice Concerns During “Stakeholder” Event in Chevy Chase

WHAT: Environmental, labor, consumer and family farm advocates critical of the pending Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP) will gather at10:30am this Wednesday outside the negotiating round’s “stakeholder” event to speak with interested reporters.  Interviews can be scheduled for other times using the contact information below. 
“These negotiations cover far more than the tariffs and quotas normally associated with ‘trade,’ delving deep into environmental, consumer safety, financial, public procurement and other public policy areas,” said Arthur Stamoulis, Executive Director of Citizens Trade Campaign. “The world cannot afford for this pact to become a back-door means of deregulation.”
WHERE: Outside the J.C. Penney Main Building
National 4-H Youth Conference Center
7100 Connecticut Avenue
Chevy Chase, MD
WHEN: 10:30am, Wednesday, October 1, 2014
VISUALS:  Activists with t-shirts and signs will also be at the 10:30am availability for photographs and b-roll.
  • Manuel Pérez-Rocha, Institute for Policy Studies. Associate Fellow. Expertise in TTIP’s repercussions outside the U.S. and Europe. 240-838-6623manuel@ips-dc.org.
  • Jeffrey Chester, Center for Digital Democracy. Executive Director. Expertise in digital privacy, digital trade, data flows and consumer protection. 202-986-2220jeff@democraticmedia.org.
  • Michael Dolan, Teamsters. Legislative Representative. Expertise in labor, public procurement, geographic indicators and services. 202-297-8097mdolan@teamsters.org.
  • Celeste Drake, AFL-CIO. Trade & Globalization Policy Specialist. Expertise in labor, procurement and investment. 202-549-5445Cdrake@aflcio.org.
  • Karen Hansen-Kuhn, Institute for Agriculture and Trade Policy. Director of International Strategies. Expertise in agriculture, GMOs, food safety and regulatory cooperation.202-413-9533khansenkuhn@iatp.org.
  • Carroll Muffett, Center for International Environmental LawPresident and CEO. Expertise in chemicals, the environment, international trade and investment. 202-425-2934Cmuffett@ciel.org.
  • Ilana Solomon, Sierra Club. Responsible Trade Program Director. Expertise in energy, the environment and investment. 202-222-5004ilana.solomon@sierraclub.org.
  • Melinda St. Louis, Public Citizen. International Campaigns Director, Global Trade Watch. Expertise in investment, regulatory cooperation and consumer protection. 202-441-7579mstlouis@citizen.org.
  • Marcus Stanley, Americans for Financial Reform. Policy Director. Expertise in financial services and consumer protection. 202-674-9885marcus@ourfinancialsecurity.org.
  • Rep. Sharon Anglin Treat, Maine State Representative. Co-chair of the Maine Citizen Trade Policy Commission. Presenting on behalf of the National Caucus of Environmental Legislators. Expertise in state concerns regarding regulatory harmonization, the environment, climate, chemicals, procurement, food policy and investment.207-242-8558satreat@gmail.com.
  • Ronald White, M.S.T., Center for Effective Government. Director of Regulatory Policy. Expertise in the U.S. regulatory process and environmental health regulations. 240-381-4075rwhite@foreffectivegov.org.

The post MEDIA AVAILABILITY: Critics of EU-US Trade Negotiations Voice Concerns During “Stakeholder” Event in Chevy Chase appeared first on Institute for Policy Studies.


ECU notes: Exercise during pregnancy – Greenville Daily Reflector

ECU notes: Exercise during pregnancy
Greenville Daily Reflector
Kim Womack of Greenville, who is expecting her first child in August, is one of 55 women enrolled in the study. A speech language pathologist for Pitt … “I hope it helps with labor and delivery and to get back in shape afterward, and to have positive


Lawsuit alleges more than 250 labor violations during Maine blueberry harvest – Press Herald

Lawsuit alleges more than 250 labor violations during Maine blueberry harvest
Press Herald
Eighteen migrant workers who came to Maine for the blueberry harvest have filed a lawsuit in U.S. District Court against a farm labor recruiter, two blueberry businesses and several housing providers, saying they were not paid for much of their work

and more »


Blaise Matuidi of France in action during the FIFA World Cup 2014 group E … – Wall Street Journal (blog)

Blaise Matuidi of France in action during the FIFA World Cup 2014 group E
Wall Street Journal (blog)
The Journal provides analysis of the final games in Group F at the 2014 World Cup, featuring Ecuador vs. France and Honduras vs. Switzerland at 4 p.m. ET. Commentary is provided by Alan Jacobs and Joe E. Melvin, with contributions from the WSJ team …
Ecuador v France: Antonio Valencia sent off as Didier Deschamps' side go Telegraph.co.uk
World Cup 2014: Ecuador and France Play to a 0-0 DrawNew York Times
France top group after failing to break down battling 10-man EcuadorThe Guardian
Bleacher Report -CBSSports.com -SB Nation
all 1,290 news articles »


Iowa boy’s dog shot during walk – Sioux City Journal

Iowa boy's dog shot during walk
Sioux City Journal
Des Moines County Sheriff's deputies arrested Cody Trails Warth, 21, 17675 Falcon Road, Thursday evening on charges of second-degree criminal mischief, a class D felony, and animal abuse and shooting a rifle across a roadway, both misdemeanors.

and more »